In 2001, I was working part-time at the Guess store in Portland, OR, having recently relocated to Portland from the Midwest. It was the second of two jobs, my other being as the closing manager in a shoe store across the street from the mall. You should have seen the faces of customers who had been shopping earlier in the day in the mall when they walked into the shoe store and did a double take. Did I ever play dumb to drive people crazy? You betcha.
Anyway, that’s mostly irrelevant. Every month, the staff at the Guess store had a Saturday morning employee meeting. Part of that meeting was to look at all the new stock that had come in and model it for each other to get a feel for how it all looked and fit. One Saturday morning, my manager had the hilarious idea of making everyone try on and model the classic fit jeans. Now, keep in mind…this was 2001. This was the era of the ultra-low rise, “bikini cut,” lace-front jeans a-la Britney Spears.
Everyone had this outfit. As in the first photo, one must stand with the back slightly arched to prevent the rear crackage from popping out. Note the forward half-scrunch in photo two, which keeps the pubes from peeking over the top of the waistband. Make sure your back is to the wall. You can’t accomplish both at once.
Guess was always very fashion-forward with their denim, but along the denim wall, there was that one cubby which housed a single size-run of classic 90s high-rise, taper-legged jeans. These are very fashion-forward in today’s world, and highly coveted in the resale market, but back then they were hideous to the young fashionista. These jeans had a small, yet faithful following of older women (probably younger than I am now, but they seemed old back then), which kept them trickling into our store.

I want these jeans. They are so cool now.
If only selfies and cell phones were a thing in 2001. Everyone looked hilarious in those jeans. Ridiculous, actually. We were all laughing so hard. The assistant manager with her petite, tanned physique nearly wet herself laughing, the waistline practically hitting her in her pits. No one looked right in those jeans.
“Melanie, go! You have to try them on, too!” my manager insisted. I was procrastinating because I had recently gained some weight. I was already struggling to fit into this brand, which was cut for teenaged bodies and tended to run small. I wasn’t really in the mood to model unflattering jeans to a room full of slightly younger, tiny little women. Reluctantly, I went into the fitting room and put them on…they fit like a glove. They felt amazing. I didn’t have to do the bend forward test to ensure all crackage remained hidden, or the bend backward test to make sure no pubes went rogue over the waistline. The waistline actually sat at my waist, not along the widest part of my hips, complete with bling and leather laces to draw even more attention to my increased girth and the fact that I didn’t fit the buxom 15-year-old ideal that the marketing on the walls around me perpetuated.
Despite how good they felt, I still assumed they’d look stupid on me, like everyone else. By now, the rest of the staff had finished and were sitting waiting for me. I walked out and everyone just looked. No one laughed. “Wow, Melanie, those look so good on you,” my manager said, wide-eyed. Everyone agreed. They were genuinely impressed by the way I looked in those jeans. But there was no way in hell I was going to actually own a pair and wear them. They were mom jeans – so NOT cool. I was young, but older than my counterparts, the only married lady, and built more womanly. Unlike Britney, who at that time was not a girl, yet not a woman, I was 100% woman. I didn’t want to look like everyone’s mom. I continued wearing trendy jeans and made sure my waistline remained crack and pube-free.
Two years later, I started naturopathic medical school. As a naturopathic physician, you have to know a LOT of human anatomy. Suddenly, the fit of clothing took on a whole new meaning and my sewing went up a notch. I learned so much about my body in school with the amount of physical medicine I was learning and experiencing. Everything became about the bony landmarks on my body – where I wanted my skirts hems to land relative to my patella; where I wanted my waistlines to hit relative to the pelvic crest and levels of certain vertebrae. People began commenting more and more on how well my me-made clothing fit my body. I was discovering that although I’m fairly tall at 5’8″, I’m long-waisted and short-legged, which is why truly high-waisted pants look good on me and shorter lengths work fine. I learned that a mid-rise was actually more low-rise on my form, and to get the look I wanted in various pant styles, I had to ignore convention. The definitions of low/mid/high rise, in my opinion, should be relative to the measurements of a person’s body, not the length of a crotch seam. But that’s mass-production for you. We are all 5’4″ with flat butts and no stomach. Which brings us to the topic at hand…
My beloved high rises are in style. Let’s be clear – vintage high rise pants are in style. Over the years, before I was making my own jeans, I was still trying to find high rise jeans that didn’t look 80s. The looks of the 80s and 90s hadn’t been gone long enough to look cool and vintage. They were just old enough to seem dowdy and outdated. There really is a sweet spot with these things, isn’t there? Everything that was considered high rise fit me as mid-rise. The only way to get the rise I wanted was to buy men’s Western-cut jeans or go true vintage. Over the past five years, though, a magical thing happened. Courtesy of social media, there are suddenly excellent choices in denim fabrics, jeans hardware, and pattern choices. Making jeans is finally in reach for the average modern sewist, and I’ve gone nuts.
The first pairs I made were Closet Case Ginger Jeans, a wonderful modern high-rise with a skinny/straight leg design:
I added 1/2 inch at the hip and 1/2 inch at the waist to adapt them to my long waist. I have made 5 pairs of Gingers, and I love them. They fit perfectly, they hit at my natural waist, and they look great with retro looks. I made a variety of high-waisted trousers after this, and finally had pants that were my style. I prefer vintage looks from the 40s and 50s, even when I’m wearing them in a modern way. I was quickly learning, though, that there are different variations on the concept of ‘high-waisted’ in terms of where the waistband sits at the waist.
When the Megan Nielsen Dawn Jeans pattern came out, I was all over it. The classic non-stretch, straight-legged version of the above would be an ideal addition to my retro-inspired jeans wardrobe.
This time, I not only added 1/2 inch to the waist for my height, I added a full inch at the hips. My instincts told me that this would give the true vintage 40s/50s look I wanted. I was right. I had my dream jeans. Both of these jeans, however, sit at my natural waist. What’s the difference, aside from overall style? I’m no fashion expert or costume historian, but here’s my theory:
For a modern high rise, the TOP of the waistband hits at the natural waist. For a vintage high rise, the BOTTOM of the waistband hits at the natural waist.
I might be wrong, and this was a really long way to make this simple statement, but after years of navigating the waistband challenge, I feel that this simple distinction is a bit life-altering. I prefer the vintage look, even when I’m dressing modern. I don’t want to look like I’m in costume, but my heart belongs to these eras. And, apparently, my body prefers these silhouettes. Going forward, I feel empowered in my sewing, because I am clear on how to get the fit and look that makes my heart sing and feels great to wear.
Vintage rise, retro nod, modern take
Occasionally, you see a headline where the media threatens the return of the low-rise jean, courtesy of some random celebrity who has the audacity to be seen in public this way, thus influencing the masses to re-visit this trend. I don’t care. I’m never going back. I’ll be sitting here in my WWII-inspired dungarees listening to Lena Horne, reading vintage sewing books, and shaking my head at the insanity.

2001 called. I let it go to voicemail.
All cards on the table… I had some leftover fabric, so I did use the Ginger jeans pattern to make one pair of low rise jeans just for kicks, according to my own measurements. I was able to make the back high enough to suit my frame. They fit like a glove:

Don’t judge me…
Thoughts From My Creative Journey